Skip to content
Independent mortgage & protection brokers, advising clients across the UK
Remortgaging

Should I remortgage if I have early repayment charges on my mortgage?

Is it worth paying an early repayment charge to secure a longer fixed rate? A real client example from December 2021 shows how we weighed it up.

A pair of new red-brick semi-detached houses with a small front garden, under a blue sky.

If you're partway through a fixed rate and thinking about a new deal, the early repayment charge is usually the first hurdle. This article looks at whether it can make sense to remortgage with early repayment charges still to pay, using a real client scenario from December 2021. It's for homeowners weighing up a longer fixed rate before their current one ends.

Published in December 2021. Rates and figures in this article were correct at the time. For where things stand today, speak to an adviser.

Key takeaways

  • An early repayment charge (ERC) is a fee for leaving a mortgage deal before the end of its deal period.
  • Paying an ERC can still make sense if the new deal saves more than it costs, or gives you certainty you value.
  • A simple check is to divide the charge by the months left on your deal to see the monthly saving you'd need.
  • Every situation is different, so advice helps you compare switching now with waiting.

What are early repayment charges?

An early repayment charge is a fee some lenders apply if you repay your mortgage, or switch it to another lender, during the deal period. That's often the initial fixed or discounted years. The charge is usually a percentage of the balance and often reduces as the deal goes on.

Your mortgage offer sets out whether an ERC applies, how it's worked out and when it ends. Many lenders also let you overpay a set amount each year without a charge.

Why clients were reviewing their fixed rates in 2021

In December 2021, the Bank of England base rate had risen to 0.25%. There was speculation that interest rates might rise further the following year to control inflation.

That raised a question for many households with an existing fixed rate. Should they review their mortgage and look at securing a longer-term fixed rate? It was one many people asked over the months that followed.

A client scenario: should they remortgage with early repayment charges?

Here's a scenario from an existing client with over two years left on a 5-year fixed rate mortgage. The clients wanted to review their options for securing a longer-term fixed rate, while rates were still comparatively low.

On our initial look, the clients had early repayment charges of approximately £1,400, so they needed to weigh up that penalty. To recover this amount over the remaining two years of their fixed rate, they would need a reduction in their monthly mortgage payment of approximately £58 a month. That's the point at which paying the ERC would pay for itself.

But if rates continued to rise, was there sense in securing a lower rate that was still available, and fixing for longer? For mortgagees not looking to move and not needing more borrowing, it could be well worth investigating, especially where the ERC is not too costly.

The figures

  • Property valuation: £285,000
  • Existing mortgage: £74,000
  • Early repayment charges: £1,400
  • Total remortgage required: £75,400
  • Mortgage term required: 25 years
  • Existing mortgage payment: £310 per month

Brief summary of potential schemes available

Scheme Rates from Monthly mortgage repayment from
5-year fixed rate 1.49% £301 to £320
10-year fixed rate 2.09% £323 to £330

Please note these figures were correct as at 21/12/2021. Rates are subject to change by lenders without notice.

What the client decided

The figures above include adding the early repayment charge to the loan. With the 5-year fixed rate, the clients could save up to £9 a month and extend their fixed rate by three years. With the 10-year fixed rate, they would pay an extra £13 to £20 a month and secure a fixed rate for a further eight years.

The clients' main aim was to fix for longer. So they chose to pay their existing lender's early repayment charges and secure a longer-term fixed rate for their own peace of mind.

How to weigh up an early repayment charge

The client example shows that the decision isn't only about the monthly payment. These steps help you think it through:

  1. Find the exact ERC, either from your latest statement or by asking your lender for a redemption figure.
  2. Divide it by the months left on your current deal. That's the monthly saving you'd need just to break even.
  3. Add any fees on the new deal, such as arrangement, valuation or legal costs.
  4. Remember that if the ERC is added to the loan, you'll pay interest on it over the term.
  5. Ask what a longer fix is worth to you in certainty, even if it doesn't save money each month.

When waiting may make more sense

If your ERC ends in a few months, waiting is often the simpler route. You can usually line up a new deal ahead of time and have it start once the charge falls away. Waiting may also suit you if you might move home or need to borrow more soon, as those plans can change which deal fits.

For a wider look at the trade-offs, see our guide to switching your mortgage mid-deal. If timing is the main question, our article on when you can remortgage before your fixed rate ends explains how lenders handle it.

Getting the timing right

Every client's situation and circumstances are different, so reviewing your options and getting professional advice is, we believe, extremely important. We don't charge for initial consultations or for providing research, so you can look at your options at no cost.

If you decide to leave the remortgage until closer to the end of your early repayment charge, MMPE can set a review to help at the right time. You can register your mortgage end date so we know when to get in touch.

Our view

An early repayment charge isn't automatically a reason to stay put. Sometimes the numbers work, and sometimes the certainty of a longer fix is worth a small cost, as it was for the clients in this example. Talk it through before you decide, and when you're ready, see your remortgage options.

No obligation. No cost to register.

Stay ahead of your mortgage renewal.

Your mortgage deal doesn't need to be ending soon for you to start planning ahead. Register your mortgage end date with My Mortgage & Protection Experts and we can contact you at the right time to review your options.

Whether your deal ends in a few months or further down the line, we'll help you stay one step ahead.

Register your mortgage end date
  1. 1
    Register your end dateNo obligation and no cost.
  2. 2
    We get in touch at the right timeBefore your deal ends, so there's time to plan.
  3. 3
    We review your optionsYour lender's offer against the wider market.

Frequently asked questions

What is an early repayment charge?

It's a fee some lenders charge if you repay or switch your mortgage during the deal period, often the fixed or discounted years. Your mortgage offer shows how it's worked out and when it ends.

How do I know if paying an early repayment charge is worth it?

Compare the charge, plus any fees, with what you'd save on the new deal over the months you have left. If the saving is bigger, or the longer fix gives you certainty you value, it may be worth it.

Can the early repayment charge be added to the new mortgage?

Sometimes, as in the client example in this article, subject to the new lender's criteria and affordability. You'll then pay interest on it over the mortgage term.

Should I wait until my early repayment charge ends?

If the charge ends soon, waiting is often simpler. If you want a longer fixed rate and the charge is small, switching earlier may make sense, so advice helps you compare both.

Do you charge for an initial consultation?

No. We don't charge for initial consultations or for the research, so you can look at your options at no cost.

All guides & news
Call us Free chat