Why mortgage brokers remain indispensable in the age of AI
Can AI replace a mortgage broker? What Santander's research found about borrowers, brokers and AI, and how technology and personal advice work together.

As artificial intelligence (AI) changes the way people research mortgages, you might wonder whether technology could ever replace the expertise of a broker. This post looks at mortgage broker vs AI through recent research from Santander, and explains where each one helps people buying or remortgaging a home.
Published in December 2025. Survey figures and rates in this article were correct at the time. For where things stand today, speak to an adviser.
Key takeaways
- Santander's research found that most borrowers still value a broker's support, even as AI tools grow.
- In the survey, 65% of borrowers said they couldn't get through the homebuying process without a broker.
- Saving money and time were the top reasons people valued brokers, alongside guidance and emotional support.
- AI can help with early research, but it can't take responsibility for advice on your circumstances.
- Technology and personal advice work best together, not as a choice of one or the other.
The human touch still matters
Recent research from Santander's Broker Perception Barometer made one thing clear. AI is a powerful tool, but brokers remain essential to the homebuying journey for most borrowers.
A mortgage is one of the biggest financial commitments most people make. It's tied up with where you live, your family and your plans for the years ahead, so it's no surprise that people want someone they can talk to.
Key findings from Santander's latest survey
- 65% of borrowers said they couldn't get through the homebuying process without a broker's support.
- Nearly 85% would use a broker again when buying or remortgaging.
- Saving money (29%) and time (26%) were the top reasons clients valued brokers, but guidance on taxes, changing rates and emotional support were also highly prized.
- 82% of clients said their broker made them feel less stressed during complex situations.
- The average borrower saved £125 per month on mortgage payments by working with a broker, with those in the South East saving as much as £155 per month.
- Despite technological advances, 63% of borrowers still relied on personal recommendations to find a broker, while only 5% turned to AI.
These are survey results, so they describe borrowers as a group. What you could save, if anything, depends on your own mortgage, income and circumstances.
Mortgage broker vs AI: what each does well
AI tools can be genuinely useful at the start. They can explain terms, help you think through questions to ask, and crunch numbers quickly. Comparison tools and calculators can give you a feel for monthly payments at different rates.
What AI can't do is replace the reassurance, tailored advice and deep market knowledge an experienced broker provides. A broker works with your real documents, such as payslips, bank statements, proof of deposit, ID and proof of address. They then match them to the lender whose criteria you're likely to meet.
Where a broker makes the difference
- Criteria, not just rates. Each lender has their own rules on income, credit history and property type, and their own affordability model.
- Building a case when your circumstances are less straightforward, such as self-employed income or past credit problems.
- Handling the conversations with lenders, estate agents and solicitors, so you don't have to chase them yourself.
- Taking responsibility for the recommendation, because mortgage advice is a regulated activity.
Where AI and technology help
- Getting to grips with the jargon before your first conversation.
- Running quick what-if sums on payments and terms.
- Keeping an eye on your mortgage after you've moved in, so you know when it's time for a review.
Why do brokers make such a difference?
In a market shaped by shifting interest rates and changing lending rules, a trusted adviser by your side helps you make sense of the options. A broker can explain why one lender suits you better than another. They can also tell you what to expect at each stage, from an initial look at what you could borrow through to picking up your keys.
At My Mortgage & Protection Experts, our team combines decades of experience with technology such as our Sussed app. Sussed shows tailored rates and costs, scans the market after you've bought and reminds you before your deal ends. That gives you up-to-date market information alongside the personal guidance needed to make confident decisions.
If you'd like to understand what that advice looks like in practice, our article on whether a mortgage adviser can get you a better deal walks through it.
The bottom line: trust, savings and stress relief
Santander's data showed that most borrowers not only saved money with a broker, but also felt more supported and less stressed throughout the process. As Graham Sellar, Head of Intermediary Channels at Santander, put it:
"AI provides support at the initial stages of deal research and exploration, but when it comes to making concrete life decisions, nothing can match the trust that is built through a broker."
Recent rate reductions and what they meant for buyers
At the time of writing, Santander had recently reduced their residential and buy to let fixed rates, with new rates starting from 3.51%. Rates have moved since, as they always do.
What doesn't change is the value of reviewing your options when your deal is coming to an end. A broker can compare your lender's offer with the wider market, so you can see whether staying or remortgaging suits you better.
How to use AI and a broker together
- Use AI tools and calculators to learn the basics and jot down your questions.
- Gather your documents so you're ready for an initial conversation.
- Speak to a qualified adviser, who can check your situation against lenders' criteria.
- Keep using technology after you move in, so you get a timely nudge before your deal ends.
Our view
AI is a helpful starting point, and we use technology ourselves to keep our clients informed. But a mortgage decision rests on your circumstances, your documents and a lender's criteria, and that's where a person who knows this world earns their keep. To see what that involves day to day, read about what a mortgage broker does.
Frequently asked questions
Can AI replace a mortgage broker?
AI can help with early research and comparing numbers. It can't check your documents against each lender's criteria, build a case for your application or give regulated advice that takes responsibility for the recommendation.
What did Santander's survey find about brokers?
Santander's Broker Perception Barometer found that 65% of borrowers said they couldn't get through the homebuying process without a broker, and nearly 85% would use one again.
How much did borrowers save by using a broker?
In the survey, the average borrower saved £125 per month on mortgage payments by working with a broker, and those in the South East saved as much as £155 per month. What you could save depends on your own circumstances.
How do people find a mortgage broker?
The survey found that 63% of borrowers still rely on personal recommendations to find a broker, while only 5% turn to AI.
Does MMPE use technology too?
Yes. Our free Sussed app shows tailored rates and costs, scans the market after you buy and reminds you before your deal ends, alongside advice from a qualified adviser.
