A deeper dive into fixed vs tracker mortgages: pros and cons
With the base rate predicted to fall in early 2024, many borrowers asked whether to fix or track. We compare variable, tracker and fixed rates, with the pros and cons of each.

This article takes a closer look at the fixed or tracker mortgage pros and cons, set against the lender's standard variable rate, so you can see how the three really differ on cost and flexibility. It is for anyone choosing a new deal, whether you are buying or your current scheme is coming to an end.
Published in February 2024. Rates and figures in this article were correct at the time. For where things stand today, speak to an adviser.
Key takeaways
- A lender's standard variable rate (SVR) is their default rate and is generally higher than their fixed, tracker and discounted deals.
- A tracker follows an index, usually the Bank of England base rate, plus a set margin.
- A fixed rate gives certainty of payment but usually comes with early repayment charges.
- Product fees and early repayment charges need to be costed in, not just the headline rate.
- In February 2024, fixed rates were generally lower than tracker rates because of the positive outlook in swap rates.
Taking a deeper dive into tracker versus fixed rate mortgages
In early 2024, with the base rate predicted to fall, many borrowers were asking whether it was time to fix their mortgage, or whether to delay a buying decision. Others wondered about the benefits of a variable or tracker deal, to let rates come down before fixing.
In this blog, we explore the differences between variable, tracker and fixed rates and the pros and cons of each. If you would like a shorter overview focused on your budget, our article on fixed vs tracker mortgages is a good place to start.
Standard variable rate mortgages
Firstly, it is important to understand what a lender's standard variable rate is. The SVR is the default interest rate set by the lender, and it is the rate borrowers usually move onto when their fixed or discounted rate period ends.
The SVR is influenced by various economic factors and by decisions the lender makes, such as responding to changes in the Bank of England base rate or to their own financial performance. Borrowers on the SVR may see their mortgage payments change, as the rate is subject to adjustment.
Generally, a lender's SVR will be much higher than the other products they offer, such as fixed, discounted and tracker deals. That means being on an SVR will generally cost more than other products that may be available to you. If you are on your lender's variable rate, it is worth reviewing your options, including a product transfer with your current lender or a move to a new one.
Tracker rate mortgages
A tracker is a type of variable rate mortgage where the interest rate is linked to a specified financial index, often the Bank of England base rate. When the index moves up or down, the mortgage rate adjusts accordingly.
Trackers typically have a set margin added to the index rate, which gives the final interest rate charged. They offer transparency, because you can follow the index and understand exactly why your rate has changed.
If you are considering a tracker, be aware that your payments may change in response to the underlying index. However, trackers can offer the potential for savings when interest rates are low or expected to reduce.
As with any financial decision, review the terms and conditions carefully and consider your circumstances before committing. For more on where a tracker can help, see our guide to the benefits of a tracker mortgage.
Fixed rate mortgages
A fixed-rate mortgage provides financial stability. You lock in a specific interest rate for an agreed period of time, so you have certainty of payment and are shielded from rate increases while the fix lasts.
The advantage lies in predictability. Whatever happens in the market, your mortgage payments stay the same, which can be particularly helpful in times of economic uncertainty, when rates are rising, or if you simply prefer to know what you are paying.
What is the downside? Fixed rates will generally have early repayment charges (ERCs). These are penalties built into the terms of the mortgage if you pay it off, or switch, within the scheme period.
You also need to be aware that if rates drop further, you could be paying more than the deals available at the time.
Fixed or tracker mortgage pros and cons at a glance
Fixed rate pros:
- Your payment stays the same for the whole deal.
- Budgeting is simpler, especially if money is tight.
Fixed rate cons:
- You will not benefit if rates fall.
- Early repayment charges usually apply if you leave early.
Tracker pros:
- Your payment falls if the base rate falls.
- Many trackers have no early repayment charges, which gives more flexibility.
Tracker cons:
- Your payment rises if the base rate rises.
- The margin above the base rate means the starting rate can be higher than a fix.
Factors to consider with variable, tracker and fixed rate mortgages
Standard variable rate and tracker mortgages are generally more popular when rates are low or expected to reduce. With a fixed rate, the price stays constant throughout the fixed period. With an SVR or tracker, if rates or the index are reducing, so will the rate you pay.
Product fees should also be taken into consideration. Variable rates tend not to have a product fee, but some tracker schemes do, and these need to be costed in when comparing options. A simple way to compare is to add the fees to the interest you would pay over the deal period, then compare the totals.
Early repayment charges also need to be factored in. Variable rates and trackers tend not to come with ERCs attached, but again, check and confirm this when comparing deals.
Could a tracker rate be beneficial if the base rate is forecast to drop?
The answer could be yes. In February 2024, most economists and financial commentators were predicting that the base rate would fall at some point over the following few months, and then steadily reduce over the next few years. This led some borrowers to consider variable and tracker mortgages, in the hope that the rate would fall below the fixed rates on offer at the time.
It is important to note that fixed rates had already been reduced and were generally a considerably lower rate than tracker deals. This is because tracker rates carry a margin, generally above the Bank of England base rate, whereas fixed rates were being priced on the positive outlook in the banking system's swap rates.
Put simply, swap rate pricing, and so the fixed rates on offer, reflected a forecast that rates would continue to fall. Interestingly though, while the general trend had been a decrease in mortgage rates, a few high street lenders announced increases to product pricing in the days before this article was written.
Making decisions and getting advice
If you are looking to buy shortly, or need to review your mortgage because it is coming to the end of a scheme period, there is a lot to consider. Should you fix for two, three or possibly five years, or hedge your bets with a tracker rate?
There is no right or wrong. The decision should be based on your personal needs and circumstances, and professional advice can give you a sounding board while you explore your options.
As a mortgage broker, MMPE deals with these questions daily. Working as an independent whole-of-market broker, we have access to a wide range of lenders, which means a wide range of products and criteria, including products that are not necessarily available on the high street.
Our view
Comparing rates alone can be misleading, because fees, early repayment charges and the margin on a tracker can change which deal really costs less. We look at the whole cost over the deal period and at how much payment movement your budget can take. When you are ready to compare, see our mortgage deals.
Frequently asked questions
What is a standard variable rate?
It is the lender's default rate, which borrowers usually move onto when a fixed, tracker or discounted deal ends. The lender sets it and can change it, and it is generally higher than their other deals.
Do tracker mortgages have early repayment charges?
Many do not, which is one of their attractions, but some do. Always check the terms before you compare a tracker with a fixed rate.
Why can fixed rates be lower than tracker rates?
Fixed rates are priced largely on swap rates, which reflect where markets expect interest rates to go. When markets expect the base rate to fall, fixed rates can come in below trackers, which carry a margin above the current base rate.
Should I include product fees when comparing deals?
Yes. A deal with a lower rate but a high fee can cost more overall than a slightly higher rate with no fee, so compare the total cost over the deal period.
What should I do if I am on my lender's standard variable rate?
It is worth reviewing your options, because the SVR is generally higher than the other deals available. An adviser can compare a new deal with your current lender against other lenders.
