Skip to content
Independent mortgage & protection brokers, advising clients across the UK
Mortgage tips

Fixed vs tracker mortgages

Should you fix your rate or track the base rate? We look at the UK mortgage market in early 2024 and how your budget can help you decide.

A row of red brick cottages with white sash windows, white front doors and a blue bench outside

In this short blog, we look at the fixed vs tracker mortgage question as it stood in the UK mortgage market in early 2024, and at how to decide whether to fix your rate or track. It is for homeowners whose deal is ending in the coming months and for buyers choosing their first mortgage.

Published in January 2024. Rates and figures in this article were correct at the time. For where things stand today, speak to an adviser.

Key takeaways

  • A fixed rate gives certainty of payment, while a tracker moves up and down with the Bank of England base rate.
  • In January 2024 the market was relatively stable, with the general trend being a decrease in rates.
  • Nobody can predict rates with certainty, so the choice comes down to your budget and how much risk you are comfortable with.
  • If your household budget is tight, a fix may give you more peace of mind.

The mortgage market in 2024: to fix or to track?

Homeowners and prospective buyers will naturally be wondering what is going to happen with mortgage rates this year. The housing market is influenced by a wide range of economic factors. Understanding what is likely to happen matters, especially for households whose rates are set to expire in the coming months.

January 2024 saw the mortgage market remain relatively stable, with the general trend being a decrease in rates as lenders competed for market share. The Bank of England maintained the base rate, which supported an environment of lower interest rates. However, several factors, such as inflation, economic growth and global events, can quickly sway interest rates.

There was renewed confidence at the time. But as we have seen over recent years with the financial impact of the Covid pandemic and Russia's invasion of Ukraine, world events can have an impact quickly, and we cannot always predict what is going to happen.

Many commentators were predicting that the UK would see a drop in the bank base rate as early as May 2024. Others were more cautious and suggested the base rate might drop in August.

Fixed-rate mortgages: certainty in uncertain times

If you are approaching the end of a fixed-rate mortgage within the next 6 to 12 months, or thinking about buying your new home, the question arises: to fix or not to fix? With a fixed rate, you lock in a specific interest rate for an agreed period. The benefit is certainty of payment for the fixed period and being shielded from any future rate increases.

The downside is that if rates drop further, you may end up paying more than the deals available at the time. Leaving a fixed rate early also usually means paying an early repayment charge, so it pays to think about how long you want to fix for.

The advantage of a fixed-rate mortgage lies in predictability. Whatever happens in the market, your mortgage payments stay the same. This can be particularly helpful in times of economic uncertainty, if interest rates are on the rise, or if you prefer to know exactly what you are paying so you can budget.

If you would like the basics first, our guide to what a fixed rate mortgage is explains how a fix works.

Tracker rate mortgages: riding the waves of change

On the flip side, tracker rate mortgages offer a different strategy. This type of mortgage is tied to the Bank of England base rate, so as the base rate moves, so does your tracker rate. If the base rate rises by 0.25%, your tracker rate rises by 0.25% too, usually from the following month, which means a higher monthly payment.

Equally, this works in reverse. If the base rate falls, your mortgage payments follow suit. Choosing a tracker requires a degree of comfort with uncertainty, because while you may benefit if the base rate stays stable or falls, there is always the risk that it rises and increases your monthly payments.

The crystal ball conundrum

Predicting the exact path of mortgage rates is extremely hard. Economic conditions can shift, and global events can send ripples through financial markets. That is why advisers generally ask homeowners to weigh up their attitude to risk and their financial goals, rather than trying to guess the next rate move.

A key consideration is how tight your household budget is. If your budget is relatively tight, you may be better off fixing your mortgage and giving yourself certainty and peace of mind. If you have more flexibility, a tracker could be of benefit, especially if the commentators are right and the base rate starts to drop.

Fixed vs tracker mortgage: how to decide

It can help to work through a few questions before you choose:

  1. If your monthly payment rose by a noticeable amount, could your budget cope without strain?
  2. Do you have savings to fall back on if payments went up for a while?
  3. Do you expect to move home, sell or repay a lump sum during the next few years?
  4. Would a payment that changes from time to time worry you, even if you could afford it?

If your answers lean towards needing certainty, a fix is usually the more comfortable choice. If you have spare room in your budget and plans that may change, a tracker's flexibility can be attractive, as many trackers have lower or no early repayment charges. Our Financial Resilience Calculator can help you see how much of a cushion your household has.

It is also worth looking at the whole deal, not just the rate. Arrangement fees, early repayment charges and the length of the deal all affect what you will pay. For a side-by-side look at standard variable, tracker and fixed rates, including fees and charges, read our deeper dive into fixed and tracker mortgage pros and cons.

Seeking professional guidance

Whether you lean towards fixing or tracking, professional advice is important. As a broker, MMPE can give you insight tailored to your situation, helping you make informed decisions that fit your financial goals and circumstances.

In early 2024, the UK mortgage market was characterised by stability, but the future remained uncertain. Homeowners with rates coming to an end, and home buyers, needed to weigh up the pros and cons of fixing or using tracker or variable rates, with thought given to their attitude to risk, household budget and financial goals. That approach still holds whatever the market is doing.

Our view

There is no right or wrong answer to fixed or tracker, only the one that fits your budget and how you feel about risk. We would rather you choose a deal you can live with comfortably than one that relies on guessing the next rate move. Talk to one of our independent advisers and see your mortgage options.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a fixed and a tracker mortgage?

A fixed rate stays the same for an agreed period, so your payment does not change. A tracker moves in line with the Bank of England base rate, so your payment rises or falls when the base rate does.

Is a tracker mortgage cheaper than a fixed rate?

Not always. It depends on the margin the tracker charges above the base rate, the fixed rates on offer at the time and what happens to the base rate during the deal.

Who might suit a fixed rate mortgage?

A fix can suit people with a tight household budget, or anyone who prefers to know exactly what they will pay each month. It gives certainty for the length of the deal.

Who might suit a tracker mortgage?

A tracker can suit people who have room in their budget to absorb a rise in payments and who are comfortable with some uncertainty. They may benefit if the base rate falls.

When should I start looking if my fixed rate is ending?

It is sensible to start looking around 6 to 12 months before your deal ends. That gives you time to compare options and, with many lenders, secure a new rate in advance.

All guides & news
Call us Free chat